Calls grow for senior driver safety reforms following tragic death of 3-year-old in Edinburgh

Facebook
LinkedIn
Close up of senior man's hands on steering wheel

The rule governing senior drivers is being re-examined four years after the tragic death of Xander Irvine, a three-year-old boy who was murdered when an elderly driver in Edinburgh lost control of her vehicle.

The sheriff principal, Nigel Ross, stated during a public investigation into the deadly accident that happened on June 30, 2020, that Edith Duncan, 91, who had undetected dementia, should never have been operating a motor vehicle.

Currently, drivers in the UK are required to renew their licenses at the age of 70 and then every three years after that. They must disclose any illness or handicap that may impair their ability to drive as part of that process, such as dementia, diabetes managed with insulin, Parkinson’s disease, epilepsy, and neurological or visual problems.

Ross called the system “significantly defective” and said that only drivers under the age of 80 should be able to self-certify, with any license renewal at that age requiring a cognitive evaluation.

Ross claimed that the form should be enlarged to obtain a more complete picture of applicants’ fitness to drive, saying, “[The current system] fails to identify unfitness to drive in applicants who either deliberately or unintentionally fail to give correct information on the relevant application form.”

“It fails to recognise that driving ability may decline with age, or that dementia sufferers may be unaware of their own condition.”

However, any change to the current situation would require new government legislation, which is made more difficult by the widespread belief among road safety experts that older drivers do not present a higher risk.

“As a cohort, older drivers are not more dangerous than middle-aged groups,” said Professor Charles Musselwhite of Aberystwyth University, a leading authority on the relationship between ageing and driving.

“There is an increase in numbers in official statistics, but that is because reporting only includes injuries and deaths, and as such those aged 75 and above will more likely appear there due to fragility; they are more likely to be injured or killed from collisions they would have walked away from in middle age.”

According to government casualty figures, young male drivers are ‘four times as likely to be killed or seriously injured’ as more experienced drivers, demonstrating that younger drivers are more likely to be engaged in collisions.

According to Musselwhite, older adults are more inclined to follow traffic laws, especially those pertaining to speed restrictions, and they also take less chances. Additionally, he contends that older drivers make up for the physical changes that come with ageing, such as “poorer eyesight, poorer hearing, changes in working memory, slower reaction times,” by driving more cautiously and avoiding uncomfortable situations, like driving at night or during rush hour.

According to data from the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency, around 6 million adults in the UK who are 70 years of age or older now possess a valid driver’s license. Approximately 1.6 million of those drivers are 80 years of age or older.

Over 150,000 drivers are 90 years of age or older, which is double the figure from ten years ago, according to data released by the DVLA earlier this year.

However, Rob Heard, the chair of the Older Drivers Forum and a road safety sergeant with the Hampshire police, agrees that there is no threat from the increasing number of elderly drivers on our roads.

“When we get into our middle age we are safest and then, when we get to around 80 years old, things change again and risk increases,” said Heard.

“We all age differently: there are drivers in their 40s who are no longer fit to drive, but likewise there are drivers in their late 90s and 100s who are perfectly fit to drive. However, ageing can creep up on us all, often without us realising the effects it can have.

“I do feel we should have compulsory eyesight testing at licence renewal at the age of 70 years and every licence renewal thereafter. Research shows that 90% of driving is visual and we need to see hazards on the road to avoid them.”

Heard is doing this by reiterating a nationwide vision and driving campaign that calls on police departments across to verify that drivers can read a license plate at the legally mandated 20-meter distance.

The program, called Is Your Vision Roadworthy?, was first tested in February and March of last year. It collected information from 898 drivers, 17 of whom had their licenses revoked.

The average age of the disbarred motorists was 70.6 years.

But Heard admits that not all senior accidents are brought on by deteriorating vision, with “hearing, reaction time, and judgement of speed and distance” possibly “not as sharp as it once was.”

These elements surely had a part in Xander Irvine’s death, which Ross said was caused by Duncan’s cognitive disability. She passed away before she could be prosecuted. According to Ross, a more thorough evaluation of the pensioner’s driving skills and the cancellation of her licence would have resulted from an assessment of her mental acuity prior to the tragic accident.

Heard says he would support “any idea that would make sure we are all safe to drive, as long as it is fully tested and shown to make a difference”.

Although many elderly persons would appreciate their general practitioner’s advise on whether to quit driving, doctors frequently respond that they are not qualified to recognise the circumstances that could lead to such a choice. Furthermore, there is less evidence that tests of driving skill, medical conditions, or cognitive abilities have any bearing on the crash rates of older drivers, as Musselwhite notes.

“Countries that have more stringent tests have no fewer road traffic collisions for, or by, that age group,” said Musselwhite. “Famously, Denmark introduced a medical test via a GP and then took it out, as it made no difference. We need more evidence as to what might work before we make a change.”

For those on the accident frontline, however, bitter experience is frequently all the evidence required to make the case for legislative reform.

“I’ve seen firsthand the tragic outcomes of accidents involving elderly drivers,” said one experienced firefighter, speaking on condition of anonymity.

“While I understand the importance of independence, particularly for those over 70, it’s concerning when drivers in their 80s or 90s are still behind the wheel without regular assessment.

“I’ve responded to several calls where an older driver has mistakenly hit the accelerator instead of the brakes – something I’ve never seen with younger drivers. I would fully support the introduction of a regular testing system for drivers over 80 to ensure both their safety and the safety of others.”

The number of drivers over 70 who were engaged in a collision that caused death or serious injury increased by 12%, from 3,082 to 3,451, between 2004 and 2023. Accidents involving other drivers that resulted in death or serious injury decreased by 45% during that time, from 37,023 to 20,397.

According to a YouGov survey from last summer, 65% of Britons would support legislation requiring drivers to retake their driving exams when they turn 70.

Change is not without precedent, but it will not be simple to change the existing quo. Following the 2011 death of 16-year-old Cassie McCord, who was hit by an 87-year-old driver’s car, new regulations known as “Cassie’s law” were implemented, which gave authorities the power to immediately revoke licenses.

Jackie, McCord’s mother, successfully pushed for reform when Colin Horsfall, the driver, refused to give up his licence despite failing a police vision test in the days before the tragedy.

Xander’s parents, Paul and Victoria Irvine, hope that their son’s passing may serve as a comparable impetus for changes in the law and public perception of senior drivers.

“We welcome the sheriff principal’s strong recommendations and really hope this can be the starting point for positive changes to the system,” the couple said in a statement.

“We hope that Xander’s story will go some way in changing not just the legal systems in place but also public perception towards driving in older age.”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top